The polls were wrong again, this time in the good direction. The final polling average had Democrats up 9 points nationally. They won by about 13. In some of the places with the biggest swings, the misses were even larger. That doesn’t make polls useless or junk science. But in a closely divided electorate, a normal polling error is so often decisive that it undercuts a good bit of their predictive value. Either way, it is worth remembering that this doesn’t always favor Republicans.
Claims that moderates did better than progressives are way off the mark. It is true that candidates backed by mainstream Democrats saw a small bit bigger vote shares than candidates backed by progressive groups. But:
Mainstream candidates were over-concentrated in the states with the biggest demographic swings and turnout surges. Think of the huge Hispanic turnout and swing in Texas in the face of ICE abuses, or Black voters in the South after the gutting of the Voting Rights Act and a wave of racialized gerrymandering. MAGA’s behavior, and the way these communities organized in response, drove much of the swing. Of course those states swung more than average!
The flip side: progressives were concentrated in bluer states, where wins were more certain and where, in some cases, voters are dissatisfied with blue-state governance (see Oregon).
The two most prominent “underperforming” progressive Senate candidates, Abdul El-Sayed in Michigan and Troy Jackson in Maine, didn’t actually underperform.
El-Sayed ran into a buzzsaw of bigoted campaigning, backed by more than $150 million spent against him. He still finished only about 1.5 to 2 points behind the rest of Michigan's statewide Democratic ticket. That looks like a remarkable performance to me.
Jackson did much better relative to the national vote than did Susan Collins’ previous challenger, who was a moderate. He beat Susan Collins by about 7 points, which put him roughly 6 points behind the national Democratic margin. Compare that to Sara Gideon, the establishment moderate who ran against Collins six years ago. Gideon ran about 12 points behind the national Democratic margin. And everyone nationally was so hopeful about that race that the moderate Gideon outraised Collins more than two to one. And this year, the Maine Senate race swung toward Democrats about as much as the country did. In many ways, Jackson way overperformed.The moderates all moved way left on economics. You can’t say it hurt to be progressive in this election when all the relative moderates got way more progressive and we won by a bunch.
Given that the data seems to suggest this election was even more about the composition of the electorate (who shows up, who stays home) than it was about changed teams (though that happened too), and progressives have always claimed an economically populist message would turn out the right voters - the hot take in favor of moderates is way overstated.
The Democratic Party moved way left on economics and it worked. Candidates almost universally campaigned against billionaires, corporations and corruption, and demanded that the rich pay their fair share. That has long been a Democratic theme, but this year it had a much more populist edge, even from moderates in swing districts. I was stunned to hear Ezra Klein interview both Adam Jentleson, a major centrist voice in the party, and socialist Hasan Piker, and to hear how much they all three agreed on the role that talking about taxing the rich played.
(This just shows how obscenely out of touch Washington State’s Governor was when he announced his regulatory freeze with Microsoft’s top lobbyist and the State’s business roundtable, which is dominated by big, Trump-bribing companies.)Winning did not require general cultural moderation. The more moderate candidates (moderate in context; many of them sounded like Bernie) often picked one or two ways to buck the party and show independence. But there was no systematic move to the right on cultural issues, even where those issues were de-emphasized. Candidates hammered billionaires, corruption and the cost of living, and it worked.
The absolutely moronic “America wants MAGA” take from the pundit and business class is dead. It was always stupid, because Trump's margins were thin. It may have been shocking that he won the popular vote, but he didn't win it by much, and no significant majority of voters has ever embraced MAGA, or the Republican Party since it became MAGA. 2024 was mostly part of the anti-incumbent wave that hit every rich-world government that year.
In fact, as frustrating as Biden’s decisions in his last year were, and as much as the Harris campaign drifted from solid populism to centrist-milquetoast at the urging of the Chuck Schumer-era consulting class, Democrats did notably better than other incumbent governments in 2024.So the companies like Amazon and Microsoft, the oligarchs like Zuckerberg and Huang, and the law firms and universities that capitulated to Trump weren’t just disgustingly morally bankrupt. They were also really stupid.
They should be held accountable.This election was about inflation, but it was about much more than inflation. Biden and Harris governed through a much bigger inflation wave, during a global wave of anti-inflation voting, and took a far smaller hit. Trump got absolutely punched in the neck. Voters blamed Biden less for inflation (pandemic, anyone?) than they blamed Trump (war and tariffs, anyone?). The other big drivers were immigration, the war in Iran, democracy, corruption and a desire to vote against Trump, per the polls.
Put the 2024 demographic “realignment” next to this election and you see something very new in American politics: real voter elasticity. As Hispanic voters, Black men and young men trended toward MAGA last time, things looked pretty dire, mainly because that trend had held across a lot of elections and was reaching critical levels.
But the massive swing back toward Democrats among these voters, and across almost every group, is much more movement than anything I’ve ever seen. The electorate has been so polarized, and views have felt so set in cement, that big, fast changes seemed impossible. This election earthquake suggests that was either quite wrong, or that Trump is so bad he can shake even the most polarized electorate out of its slumber. Either one is interesting and changes a lot.That means an all-states, or nearly all-states, strategy should be the future for Democratic campaigns. It’s egregious how many states we’ve written off, including opportunities the party wrote off this year (ahem, Florida). Or for short—Howard Dean was right.
People still don’t like the Democratic Party. Our brand is in the toilet. Voters turned against Trump so hard that most of us, myself included, have never seen a backlash like it. But voters haven’t remotely embraced Democrats.
The fact that the two party leaders who most embody that brand—Schumer in the Senate and Jeffries in the House—seem to think they’re entitled to keep leading is a great way to commit electoral suicide. Let’s please vote them out with some real fighters, even if those fighters aren’t as progressive as I’d like them to be.



I feel like 9 means they need to take big swings and deliver real tangible results for the middle class.
I wholly agree that the Democrats are unpopular and i believe a lot of it has to do with Schumer and Jeffries, I don't think Pelosi was well liked either. Chris Van Hollen would be step in the right direction and I'm not sure what will happen in congress but the Drmocrats can't take this opportunity lightly and need to give up their hierarchy and protocols, get tough, listen to and fight for working families. If they return to business as usual we'll have a tough 2028.